January 15, 2025

Help Safeguard Property Transactions: A Deep Dive into Seller Impersonation Fraud

Real estate fraud involves a wide range of deceptive practices targeting property transactions. Scammers may commit mortgage fraud in multiple ways, such as falsifying documents, forging ownership papers, or even intercepting financial transfers through sophisticated digital schemes. This article will concentrate on the threat of seller impersonation fraud and strategies to help protect against this type of financial crime.

Real estate transactions are significant financial investments, and unfortunately, scammers are becoming increasingly sophisticated in their attempts to exploit unsuspecting individuals. Whether you're a homebuyer, a seasoned real estate agent, or a property investor, understanding the risks of seller impersonation fraud may be crucial to protecting your assets and financial security.

Growing Real Estate Fraud in the US 

In 2023, the FBI^[i] reported 9,521 real estate fraud victims, which includes loss of funds from real estate investments or fraud involving rental or timeshare properties, with losses totaling over $145 million.  While this number encompasses internet crime in totality, and not only seller impersonation fraud, it helps to demonstrate the high number of fraudulent activities happening within the real estate industry. Additionally, according to a study^[ii] by the American Land Title Association, 28% of title insurance companies experienced at least one seller impersonation fraud attempt in 2023. These studies paint a nefarious picture, demonstrating significant fraudulent activity in the real estate industry.

How Seller Impersonation Fraud Works

Understanding how seller impersonation fraud happens may be your first line of defense. Scammers have developed increasingly complex methods to manipulate real estate transactions. These schemes typically involve carefully orchestrated processes that may include:

1. Identifying vulnerable properties (e.g., vacant, inherited, or owned by absent landlords)
2. Gathering information about the rightful owner
3. Creating fake IDs and documents
4. Listing the property for sale, often at below-market prices to attract quick offers
5. Rushing through the closing process to avoid detection
6. Vanishing with the proceeds

Unfortunately, these ploys are becoming more sophisticated by using social engineering tactics, which involve deceiving a victim to steal personal or financial information, and advanced technology to pull off the schemes.

Warning Signs to Recognize

Not all real estate transactions that seem unusual are fraudulent, but certain red flags should trigger additional scrutiny. Unusually low property prices can be a significant warning sign. While everyone loves a good deal, prices dramatically below market value should prompt careful investigation. Similarly, sellers who exclusively communicate digitally and resist in-person meetings or property tours may be attempting to hide something. Inconsistent property ownership history and requests for unconventional payment methods may also be indicators that a transaction might not be legitimate.

Protecting Investments and Transactions

Effective protection requires a multi-layered approach. Title insurance emerges as a powerful defensive tool against the consequences of seller impersonation fraud, offering potential coverage against losses from forged deeds or title defects^[iii]. Settlement services may play an equally critical role through thorough verification processes that may help detect inconsistencies or red flags before a fraudulent transaction is completed. Working with reputable title companies offering these services, like Radian Title Insurance and Radian Settlement Services may help with early identification of red flags that may indicate seller impersonation fraud.

Comprehensive Protection Strategy

Taking proactive measures can help implement a robust protection strategy and mitigate vulnerability to becoming a victim of seller impersonation fraud. Consider the following steps:

1. Identity Verification: Always confirm a seller's identity through multiple, independent channels. Do not rely solely on digital communications or a single point of contact.
2. Technological Safeguards: Leverage advanced identity verification tools that can provide an additional layer of security during transactions.
3. Continuous Education: Stay informed about the latest fraud prevention techniques. Attend industry seminars, subscribe to real estate security newsletters, and maintain an active network of professionals who can share insights and experiences.

By staying vigilant and implementing verification processes, you can help safeguard your assets from fraudulent real estate activity. Remember, if a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. Trust your instincts, ask questions, and never hesitate to seek additional verification or professional advice.  

^[i]Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report, 2023, https://www.ic3.gov/AnnualReport/Reports/2023_IC3Report.pdf

^[ii] ALTA Critical Issues Study – Seller Impersonation Fraud, July 2024, https://www.alta.org/file/Seller-Impersonation-Fraud-Study-Report.pdf  

^[iii] Exclusions and other restrictions apply. Post-policy forgery or impersonation coverage only available in certain states and requires with the purchase of an enhanced Homeowner’s Policy of Title Insurance; additional premiums apply.

©2025 Radian Group Inc. All Rights Reserved. No purchase necessary to obtain a quote. You are not required to negotiate any policy of title insurance through a particular insurance company, agent, solicitor, or broker through your use of [this or the titlegenius by Radian] platform. "Radian" and "titlegenius" are brands used with permission by Radian Group Inc.'s licensed insurance affiliates.   Title insurance is provided and underwritten by Radian Title Insurance Inc., 6100 Oak Tree Blvd, Suite 200, Independence, OH 44131; Tel: 800.362.2305, NAIC#: 51632, CA – License# 5093-0. FL – Title insurance license #51632. AZ – Title Insurer 51632 (not licensed in AK, HI, ID, IA, ME, NH, NJ, VT and WY). Title Services are provided by Radian Title Insurance Inc. and Radian Settlement Services Inc., 1000 GSK Drive, Suite 210, Coraopolis, PA 15108, Tel: 800.646.8258, FL- Non-Resident Title Agency #A271379, AZ- Non-Resident Title Agent #1800016008, both subsidiaries of Radian Group Inc. Radian Settlement Services Inc. is a title insurance agency for Radian Title Insurance Inc. Radian may designate minimum standards as to the company, terms, coverage and provisions of the policy.  Additional licenses available at https://www.mytitlegenius.com/licensing-and-disclosure-information.